• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • Departments ▼
    • FEATURED
    • IOP VACATIONS
    • REALTOR DIRECTORY
    • Entertainment & Leisure
    • Food
    • Health & Fitness
    • History
    • House & Home ▼
      • Home Services
    • People
    • Places
    • Politics
    • Real Estate ▼
      • Real Estate Articles
      • Isle of Palm’s Real Estate Experts
      • Wild Dunes Real Estate
      • Top Ten Homes Sold
    • Video
  • Special ▼
    • ISLAND REAL ESTATE
    • Wild Dunes
  • Local Podcasts ▼
    • Isle of Palms Podcast
    • Special Isle of Palms Real Estate Podcast
    • Carolina Real Estate Podcast
    • Mount Pleasant Podcast
    • Charleston Women Podcast
    • Charleston Wedding Podcast
    • Hammock Coast Podcast
  • Read ▼
    • Island Vibes
    • More Local Magazines ▼
      • Mount Pleasant Magazine
      • Charleston Women
      • MP Senior Living
      • Mt Pleasant Pets
  • Subscribe
  • Advertise ▼
    • Spreading Isle of Palms Positive Vibes
Island Vibes logo

Island Vibes

The pride of Isle of Palms yesterday, today and always.

Ruling lingers on legality of IOP resident’s seawall

Posted by IOP Mag Leave a Comment

Picture taken from the dunes of a beach front property's eroding foundation and what they're doing to combat it.After simmering for 17 months, the long-awaited rescheduled court case of an Isle of Palms resident is over. However, the judge’s ruling as to whether the seawall’s construction has legal merit is still in limbo.

Long before a trial date was set, IOP resident Rom Reddy made it clear that despite any potential legal action against him, “I am going to fight it for myself. I have a constitutional right to protect my property – I’m going to exercise those rights.”

Despite ongoing beach renourishment efforts by IOP city leaders to battle island erosion, Reddy contends that his structure is better able to withstand the waves than expensive sand, which so far has “just all gotten washed away.”

South Carolina Department of Environmental Services (DES) officials argued before Judge Ralph Anderson that Reddy violated a state law per the Coastal Tidelines and Wetlands Act of 1977 that states, “Tidelands and coastal waters are identified as ‘critical areas’ over which the Department (DES) has direct permitting authority.” More so, that such hard erosion control devices on the beachfront contribute to the deterioration of the beach, which is a public trust resource.

“Any erosion control action you take on your own can impact public use of the beach or further contribute to erosion of the area,” said Steven Traynum, coastal engineer consultant for IOP City and president of Coastal Science & Engineering in Columbia. “Rapidly eroding shorelines are a very difficult management issue. Residents taking matters into their own hands to protect their land and home from erosion can lead to making matters worse.”

From 2008-14, more than 100,000 cubic yards of sand have been dumped along the eastern fill area of Seascape and Ocean Club near Wild Dunes Resort. The seawall construction under legal review is situated on the far end of Front Beach adjacent to Breach Inlet.

Evidence of what seawall erosin looks like on Isle of Palms, SC.“We’ve been dealing with extensive erosion along the Breach Inlet area since summer 2023,” Traynum said in 2024. “City leaders have been doing everything they can and trying to hold the line until the Army Corps of Engineers can add about half a million cubic yards of sand to the south end area. That project is expected to occur in the next couple of months.”

Despite all these arguments, Anderson requested that each side look over the case transcripts and then prepare a proposed order (legal document) outlining the terms to the court for further review.

“This kind of procedure of reviewing proposed orders is not unusual at the ALC (Administrative Law Court),” said Leslie Lenhardt, senior managing attorney with the South Carolina Environmental Law Project, which represented the Coastal Conservation League in the case. “And proposed orders are just another way for each side to present their case, and for the judge to make a further analysis.”

Once the transcripts become available, the parties will have 30 days to submit the proposed orders. “Then the judge will rule on the merits,” Lenhardt said.
If the ruling ultimately favors Reddy, Lenhardt noted it could establish precedent for other coastal residents to install similar structures, leading to more shoreline damage with increased erosion, disruption of the beach’s natural cycle and impacts to wildlife that use the beach, such as sea turtles and endangered bird species.

If the ruling ends up favoring DES, Reddy would have to pay a levied fine of $289,000 and take down the wall. “Reddy has indicated that if he loses, he will appeal the case,” Lenhardt said.

In the case of McQueen v. South Carolina Coastal Council heard before the Supreme Court of South Carolina in 2003, court documents recorded the following: “The State has the exclusive right to control land below the high-water mark for the public benefit.” Under this precedent, DES would need to prove that the beach around Reddy’s structure is above the high-water mark.

Until a ruling is determined, the seawall will remain standing.

“Every day that Reddy’s seawall is allowed to stand, it has negative impacts,” Lenhardt added. “I’m hoping we can have a resolution to this case by July or early August.”

By L. C. Leach III

Related

Cars parked along the road in Isle of Palms, South Carolina.IOP Hires Parking Service, Frees Up Police For Higher-priority Calls Isle of Palms, SC owner 'retention wall' photoCourt to Determine Fate of IOP Property Owner’s ‘Retention Wall’ Living room photo in a rental. Photo credit Leon Seibert on Unsplash.comNovember Referendum to Resolve IOP Short-term Rentals Issue

Filed Under: Environment, Island Vibes Story

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Search This Site

Follow us and Help Spread Positive Vibes

Connect with us on Facebook
Connect with us on Instagram
 
Read Island Vibes. The pride of Isle of Palms today, tomorrow and always.
Ad: Carolina Real Estate Podcast. Click and go watch & listen to valuable real estate podcasts that may help you save on your next real estate transaction!
Ad: The Isle of Palms Podcast. Listen. Watch. Learn.
Pleasant Family Dentistry in Mount Pleasant, SC. Experience the BEST, and find out why we've been awarded 7 times in the BEST of MOUNT PLEASANT!
Ad: Check out dream home 34 Waterway Island Drive in Wild Dunes.

Online Magazine

Recent

  • Island-wide manhunt ends in successful capture, several injured
  • Two Swimmers Drown in Breach Inlet’s Deadly Currents: Warning signage now in multiple languages
  • Ruling lingers on legality of IOP resident’s seawall
  • Community group replants palm tree donation plan
  • Reeling in Memories Father & Son Fishing Duos

Footer Widget Header

Isle of Palms Magazine - family of sites logo
Mount Pleasant Magazine - family of sites logo
North Mount Pleasant Magazine - family of sites logo
Sullivan's Island Magazine - family of sites logo

Footer

BE PREPARED!

Disaster Preparedness Plan [PDF]

Copyright © 2025 Isle of Palms Magazine. All Rights Reserved.

Cleantalk Pixel